Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, 1275 York
Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10021, USA
It is a personal pleasure to introduce my friend and former colleague,
Donald Metcalf.
He is best recognized as one of the founding fathers of modern experimental
hematology, but we should not forget his pioneering work on the
thymus. From 1956 and the decade thereafter, Don undertook a series
of elegant studies on thymic cell kinetics and was one of the first
to analyze the impact of thymectomy and thymic grafting on lymphopoiesis.
Indeed, he should be considered the first to demonstrate the effects
of thymectomy on lymphoid tissue and the autonomous control of lymphocyte
proliferation within the thymus. In addition, his analysis of leukemogenesis
in AKR mice is still considered definitive, revealing his ability
to compare and contrast the cellular biology of the normal and neoplastic
to gain insight into the etiology and pathogenesis of leukemia.
The same consummate skills as an experimentalist, and the same insight
and interest, were to mark his subsequent investigations into myelopoiesis
and myeloid leukemia that have occupied the last two decades. I
had known and admired Don's work during his "thymic phase," since
I also began my research career on thymic development, and it was
this area that led me to move from England to Australia in 1967
to begin what was to be a 7-year collaboration with Don. Why, you
may ask, did Don move out of the thymus area at the very time that
it became a major preoccupation of immunologists? To understand
this you must understand the environment, the man, and the interplay
of chance and the prepared mind. In 1965 the Nobel Laureate, Sir
Mac Farlane Burnet, retired as Director of the Walter and Eliza
Hall Institute for Medical Research (WEHI), appointing as his successors
his two proteges, Gus Nossal as Director and Don Metcalf as Assistant
Director and Head of the Cancer Research U nit. This was a wise
decision, since Don remained relatively unburdened by administrative
responsibilities, which he naturally finds irksome, and was able
to pursue his scientific interests. The "golden age of immunology"
can be considered to have begun in the mid-1960s and the Hall Institute
was very much at the forefront. Don has always disliked the "bandwagon"
concept of research, choosing instead to move in his own directions
and as much as possible into uncharted territory. At this time,
experimental hematology was emerging from its lowly status as a
descriptive morphological discipline, helped by radioisotope labeling
kinetics and the first stem cell assay (CFU-S), as well as some
knowledge about erythropoietin and regulation of erythropoiesis.
While vision and concepts are necessary to move a field, there is
a third essential, the catalyst of methodology. Hematology lacked
in vitro systems for quantitation of hematopoietic cell proliferation
and differentiation, and so an important milestone was reached in
1965 when Don, with Dr. Ray Bradley, developed a semisolid culture
technique, permitting the clonal growth and maturation of granulocytes
and macrophages, from committed precursors in the bone marrow. This
technique was subsequently modified by him and his colleagues to
permit the clonal culture of eosinophils, megakaryocytes, B-Iymphocytes
and multipotential cells. With the use of these clonal culture techniques
and cell separation procedures, he and his collaborators succeeded
in characterizing hematopoietic stem cells and progenitor cells.
His analysis of the growth requirements of granulocytes and macrophages
led to the discovery of a group of specific glycoprotein regulators,
the colony stimulating factors (CSFs). All four murine CSFs have
been purified by his group, and work by his group and others has
now led to the cloning of cDNAs for all four murine and human CSFs.
His recent work, using bacterially synthesized recombinant CSFs,
has shown that the CSFs' function in vivo is to control the production
and function of granulocytes, monocytes, and related blood cells.
In this era of mega buck science, it is instructive to remember
that much of the pioneering work and the seminal observations were
made in agar cultures using tools no more sophisticated than a microscope,
a handheld micropipette, glass slides, and orcein stain. To the
requirements of vision, technical expertise, and powers of observation,
there must be added "Chance, Fortune, Luck, Destiny, Fate, Providence
which determine whether you walk to the right or left of a particular
tree ..." I think this is best illustrated by recalling the circumstances
surrounding the murine myelomonocytic leukemia WEHI-3. This tumor
arose very early in a very large experiment on mineral oil induction
of plasmacytomas in BALB/c mice, being carried out by Noel Warner
and myself. Not only was this tumor unique among all the hundreds
of tumors that subsequently developed, it was exactly the right
tumor (myelomonocytic leukemia), with the right properties (responded
to CSFs by proliferation or differentiation, produced CSFs, cloned
in agar), in the right place (Cancer Research Unit, WEHI), at the
right time (1968-1969), when our interests were extending from the
role of growth factors in normal myelopoiesis to regulatory aberrations
in myeloid leukemia. Studies on WEHI-3 led to subsequent studies
in which human myeloid leukemic populations were shown to remain
CSF -de pendent for cell proliferation, but one CSF , G-CSF, also
had the property of suppressing myeloid leukemic cells by enforced
differentiation. While showing that myeloid leukemia development
need not involve autocrine mechanisms, Don and his group have recently
shown that the genes for GM-CSF and interleukin-3 (IL-3) can function
as proto-oncogenes. It is exceedingly unlikely that WEHI-3 would
have been analyzed to the extent it was if it had developed elsewhere
and one wonders without it how long it would have taken to "discover,"
purify, and clone IL-3 and G-CSF, since both growth factors were
discovered as a direct result of the use of the WEHI-3 cell lines
as constitutive sources of IL-3 and as specific responders to G-CSF
. Early in 1986 I had the pleasure of attending a Birthday Party
Symposium at the Hall Institute to celebrate the 21st anniversary
of the discovery of the in vitro hematopoietic colony assay. It
was very much a coming-of age party for experimental hematology,
heralding its own golden age, which Don was so instrumental in creating.
For those who attended the final party, the image of Don Metcalf,
Ray Bradley, Leo Sachs, and Bun McCulloch, festooned with colored
balloons of varying sizes representing the cellular and regulatory
aspects of their respective contributions to hematology, was a vision
better seen than described. What was also evident was the contribution
that Don has made in inspiring the second, and what is now the third
generation of "new wave" experimental hematologists. Don's contributions
were recognized by his recent award of the Wellcome Prize of the
Royal Society which is, I am sure, just the beginning of a succession
of recognitions for his pioneering role in the modern era of hematology
and leukemia research. Your work has not only led to the discovery
and characterization of hematopoietic growth factors, but as a former
clinician (1953, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, Sydney), the initiation
of clinical trials with recombinant growth factors must be a source
of satisfaction to you ("Only if they are done right," I hear you
say).
With these words, ladies and gentlemen,
it is my distinct personal pleasure to present to you
an extraordinary scientist, Dr. Donald Metcalf.
|