National Cancer Institute Clinical Oncology Branch. Baltimore Cancer
Research Center. 22 S Greene Street. Baltimore. Maryland 21201.
USA
The first of six presentations in this poster session to be discussed
is that of Preisler and Rustum [I]. This paper demonstrates the
efficacy ofanthracycline derivatives given as a pulse injection
daily for 3 days in combination with a continuous seven day infusion
of cytosine arabinoside for the treatment of acute nonlymphocytic
leukemia (ANLL). This regimen and regimens similar to it [2] are
among the best treatments for this disease at the present time.
A number of investigators have achieved complete responses on the
order of 65-70% with such treatment [3-5]. Preisler and Rustum attempt
to determine whether the intracellular retention of activated Ara-C
in vitro by a patient's bone marrow leukemic cells correlates with
remission rate and duration. Unfortunately, the authors did not
find an improved remission rate in those patients who retained phosphoralated
cytosine arabinoside better than others. However, there was a highly
statistically significant correlation between phosphorolated cytosine
arabinoside retention and remission duration. This is an important
finding not only because it may allow one to predict in broad strokes
what remission duration is likely to be in a given patient, but
the data strongly suggest that the induction therapy given to a
patient with ANLL is the most important determinant of remission
duration. Others have also suggested this may be so [6]. A number
ofinvestigators have recently questioned the value of intensive
maintenance therapy in this disease and the results have been variable
[7,8]. Perhaps further studies of this kind will allow for more
selective and therefore more successful therapy in terms of remission
induction and duration of response. Similar work by others [9] suggests
that this may already be partly true for solid tumors. The paper
by McCredie et al also concerns ANLL treatment [10]. This paper
further confirms the efficacy of the anthracycline-cytosine arabinoside
combination with different doses and schedules of the drug. The
combination of adriamycin. vincristine, cytosine arabinoside, and
prednisone produced a 74% complete response rate at M. D. Anderson
Hospital and a 54% complete response rate in the Southwestern Oncology
Group. Group studies always give poorer results than studies performed
at single institutions that specialize in the treatment of the disease
entity in question. Substituting rubidazone [ 11 ], anew anthracycline
currently undergoing trial in France and in the United States, for
adriamycin in older patients produced essentially the same complete
response rate as that of the adriamycin containing combination.
Therefore, there is no advantage gained by substituting rubidazone
for adriamycin. It is somewhat disappointing that this new anthracycline
derivative is not more active than the two (adriamycin and daunorubicin)
already in widespread use. A good deal ofanalog research has occurred
in cancer chemotherapy with the hope that refinement of a molecule
with proven activity might lead to a greater therapeutic index.
Unfortunately, this has not been the case thus far with the anthracyclines,
the nitrosoureas, the antipurines and the antipyrimidines, or the
actinomycinmythramicin antibiotics. Perhaps this is not too surprising
when one considers that analog research in the aminoglycoside antibiotics
and, indeed. in the cardiac glycosides has not yielded a major improvement
over the respective parent compound. The study of McCredie et al.
includes anew approach to remission maintenance. The late intensification
program at M.D. Anderson Hospital has been reported previously [
12]. The present data suggest that roughly half of the patients
who undergo this program remain in unmaintained complete remission
for significantly longer periods of time than reported with other
relatively intensive maintenance programs. The data also suggest
that if the patient remains in continuous complete remission for
24 months following the discontinuation of late intensification
therapy, he has a 90% chance of remaining in complete remission.
We will watch these data with intense interest over the next months
and years with the hope that they continue to be as impressive as
they are at the present time. The McCredie paper also describes
another novel approach to remission maintenance, use of autologous
bone marrow transplantation using marrow collected and stored from
patients with ANLL during periods of remission. Too few patients
have been entered on this aspect of the study to date to allow full
evaluation or even significant optimism at this point. One might
not be surprised, however, if this method ends in failure. Spiegleman
et al. [13] have shown that even during complete remission reverse
transcriptase may be isolated from what appear to be normal granulocytes
in the peripheral blood ofANLL patients. Therefore, one might expect
that the viral etiologic agent. if there is one, might also be present
in the morphologically normal appearing cells used for these autologous
transplants. One cannot be too optimistic about transplanting cells
that may harbor pathologic time bombs. The third paper of this series
is that of Freeman et al. [14] concerning intermediate dose methotrexate
in childhood acute lymphocytic leukemia (ALL). The purpose of Freeman.s
study is to prevent the development of CNS leukemia without employing
cranial radiotherapy by administering relatively high doses ofparental
methotrexate that will result in therapeutic CSF levels of the drug.
Additionally, the goal of the study is to eradicate leukemic cells
in other sanctuaries such as the testes. In the studv. children
are induced with a combination ofsteroid. vincristine, L-asparaginase
and intermediate doses of methotrexate (500 mg/M2). The methotrexate
is followed by citrovorum factor. The idea of this study has merit.
More and more undesirable effects ofcommonly employed methods ofCNS
prophylaxi.s (intrathecal methotrexate and cranial irradiation)
arc coming to light with time [ 15, 16]. It might have been more
reasonable, however. to~ design the study so that l-asparaginase
was given after the high-dose methotrexate. In this way l-asparaginase
might not only be used as a therapeutic agent with activity against
All but as a methotrexate reversal agent which would obviate the
need for citrovorum factor [17]. This might be an important consideration
since high dose parenteral methotrexate would still enter CSF and
brain, but L-asparaginase would not. Variable amounts of citrovorum
factor enter CSF. The results of this study are of interest. Complete
remission was achieved in 96% of patients but there were 7 CNS relapses
according to the paper. For reasons that are totally unclear to
me, two patients who presented with CNS leukemia are included in
this study (one relapsed with CNS leukemia). It would have been
perfectly reasonable to exclude patients from admission to the study
if they presented with CNS leukemia since one of the goals of the
study is to evaluate this regimen for its potential to prevent CNS
leukemia. One can conclude from the study that this method of CNS
prophylaxis probably is better than no prophylaxis at all. However,
it is not clear that it is equal to or superior to more standard
cranial irradiation and intrathecal methotrexate administration.
In addition, the fact that intrathecal methotrexate was also given
to these patients makes my interpretation of these results even
more difficult since others [18] have suggested that intrathecal
methotrexate alone may be sufficient. The paper by listeret al.
[19] concerns 62 adult patients with All who received adriamycin,
vincristine, prednisone and l-asparaginase in a program based on
lessons learned from childhood All. The complete response rate in
the study was 69%. This is one more paper that indicates that combinations
of anthracyclines, vincristine, glucocorticoids, and l-asparaginase
and other drugs can produce complete responses in adults with All
on the order of70%, as previously reported by Henderson [20] and
Capizzi [21]. This study and ones similar to it represent significant
advances in the treatment of this disease. Cranial irradiation and
intrathecal methotrexate were given as CNS prophylaxis. A standard
dose of methotrexate not related to body surface area was used intrathecally
in all patients. This makes sense since almost all adults have a
CSF volume of approximately 150cc. irrespective ofbody surface area.
Such practice will decrease the number ofinadvertant overdose.s
of intrathecal methotrexate [22]. As maintenance therapy, patients
received oral 6-mercaptopurine oral methotrexate and oral cyclophosphamide.
I question the usefulness of cyclophosphamide in this regard since
data in children from St. Jude's Children's Hospital in Memphis
has shown that as one multiplies the num ber of drugs used during
maintenance, one multiplies the complications to be expected and
does very little to improve the remission duration [23]. In my opinion,
cyclophosphamide is a drug with marginal activity in All and is
more likely to be hazzardous than helpful. I cannot help but wonder
whether the one patient who died at home during an influenza epidemic
while in complete remission may not have been a cyclophosphamide
casualty. The maintenance therapy was continued for three years
and then stopped. I agree with the concept, but would have been
more pleased to see half the patient.s randomized to dinscontinue
naintenance and the other half randomized to have treatment continued.
That kind ofcomparative informa tion about a crucial question, that
is whether or not one can safely take an acute leukemia patient
in remission off maintenance therapy at some period in time needs
to be developed. The remission dura tion median of 21 mon ths in
this study represents some of the best data of this kind. The faCt
that 7 patients have already been in continuous complete remission
for more than three years is encouraging. but not different from
the early observations in other studies of similar design. In an
attempt to identify features on presentation that might influence
remission duration. the authors round that age was not a factor
as have other investigators. They did find, as have others. that
patients with hepatosplenomegaly on admission have, on the average.
shorter remission durations than patients with less disease bulk.
and they found that patients who have extremely high white counts
on admission relapse relatively quickly. Cytochemical and cell surface
marker studies gave the same results that have been reported by
others for childhood ALL. This study confirms the ract that adult
ALL behaves much the same as childhood ALL and responds to the same
kind of therapeutic manipulations. The question then comes up as
to whether or not separate studies need to be designed for children
and adults with ALL. It would appear from these data and other studies
that children and adults might be treated on the same protocols
with the same stratifications applied to both. The paper by Catovsky
et al. [24] concerns ultrastructure and cell marker studies in Iymphoproliferative
disorders. The authors contend, and rightly so, that surface marker
studies and electron microscopic studies increase the accuracy of
subclassification of the acute leukemias. They carefully define
the morphology and cell surface marker study results in various
Band T cell disorders. They conclude that these studies are useful
and no one doubts this. I do take issue, however, with their idea
that prolymphocytic leukemia is a disorder separate and distinct
from chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL). It seems to me most likely
that what has been called prolymphocytic leukemia by these authors
is simply middle or end stage CLL. Many patients with CLL end up
with lymphocytes in the marrow and peripheral blood that are younger
than those which were demonstrated at the time of diagnosis. An
occasional patient with CLL terminates with what appears to be a
blastic crisis based on the immature nucleolated morphology of the
leukemic cells at or near the time of death [25]. I see no scientific
or clinical reason for separating this disorder out from CLL since
the treatment for Catovsky's prolymphocytic leukemia is not different
from that of resistant CLL. The last paper in this series is by
Mertelsmann et al. [26], and it concerns marker studies in hematologic
malignancies. The authors characterized malignant cells by terminal
deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT) activity, CFS-c assays. and cell
surface marker studies. They have found, as have others [27] that
TdT activity is highly specific for lymphoid neoplasms and that
TdTpositivity approaches 100% in acute lymphocytic leukemia. In
addition. approximately one-third of patients with the blast phase
of chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML-BC) have TdT positive blasts.
An extremely important observation from this study is that acute
leukemia patients whose blasts are TdT positive almost always respond
to vincristine and prednosine, whereas TdT negative patients do
not This correlation ofTdT with response remains valid even when
the standard morphological examinations are inconclusive. In addition,
the majority of the CML-BC patients who responded to chemotherapy
were TdT positive. It must therefore be concluded from this study
and similar ones [27] that bone marrow TdT assay is a powerful aid
in determining type of acute leukemia and in predicting response
to therapy. This study also defined 4 cases of morphological acute
myelomonocytic leukemia associated with cell marker data consistent
with a double stem cell lineage. Other recent evidence suggests
a stem cell capable of both myeloid and lymphoid differentiation
as the site of the major lesion in some acute leukemias [28]. The
fact that myeloid-appearing cells in CML blast crisis can exhibit
TdT activity [27] suggests that such a common stem cell may be deranged
in many cases ofCML-BC. The absence of the Philadelphia chromosome
in lymphocytes found in the chronic phase ofCML has been considered
evidence against a common Iymphoid-myeloid stem cell in nature.
However. cytogenetic examination of lymphocytes obtained during
the chronic phase of the disease from patients who have sustained
the chronic phase for 5 to 10 years may shed some light on this
important question. In those patients, all lymphocytes would have
been formed since the development of the CML. whereas many lymphocytes
present at the time of diagnosis would have been formed prior to
the advent of the disease with its marker chromosome. Such studies
as these and those of Mertelsmann may eventually lead to abetter
understanding of the origin of some hematologic malignancies. References
I, Prcis1er. Ho., Rustum. Y. M,' Prediction of therapeutic responsc
in acute myclocytic Icukemia, In' Modern trends in human leukemia
III Ncth. R, Hofschneidcr. P-H. Mannweiler. K ( eds,). pp, 93-98
Berlin. Heidclberg. New York Springer 1979 2 Yates. J W. Wallace.
J" Ellison. R R,. Holland. J F,' Cytosine arabinoside and daunorubicin
therapy in acute nonlymphocytic Icukcmia Cancer Chemother, Rep 57,485-488
(1973) 3 Chang. P. Wicrnik. P. Bachur. N. Stollcr. R. Chabncr. B'
Failurc to prcdict rcsponsc of acute nonlymphocytic Icukcmia (ANLL)
using assays for dcoxycytidinc kinasc (K) cytidinc deaminasc (0).
and daunorubicin reductasc (Rcd) Proc '\mcr Soc Clin Oncol 18, 352
(1977) 4 Cassilcth. PA. Katz. M ~ Chemothcrapy for adult acute nonlymphocytic
lcukcmia with daunorubicin and cytosine arabinoside Canccr Treal
Rep 61, 1441 1445 (1977) 5 Omura. G A Voglcr. W R. Lynn. MJ A controllcd
clinical trial of chemothcrapy vs BCG immunotherapy vs no furthcr
therapy. in remission maintcnancc ofacutc myclogen ous Icukemia
(AML) Proc Amcr SOC (lin Onco)118, 272 ( 1977) 6 Burkc. PJ. Karp.
J E. Brainc. H (1. Vaughan. W P' Timcd sequcntial thcrapy of human
lcukcmia bascd upon the response oofleukemic cells to humoral growth
factors Cancer Rcs 37,2138-2146(1977) 7 Fmbury. S H. Elias. L. Hcller.
P H. Hood. C E. Grcenberg P L. Schrier. S L Remission maintcnance
therapy in acute myelogeno)us leukcmia Wcsl J Mcd 126,267-272 (1977)
8 Lewis. J P Linman. J W. Pa.iak. T, F,. Bateman. J R Effect of
maintenance chemothcrapy on survival in adults with acutc non-lymphocytic
leukemia Clin Res 24, 158A (1976) 9 Salmon. S E. Hamburger. A, W.
Oehnlen. B S. Durie. B G. Albcrts. 0 S. Moon. T E Quantitation of
differential sensitivity of human-tumor stem cells to anticancer
drugs N. Engl.J.Med.298,1321-1327(1978) 10. McCredie, KB, Keating,
M.J., Dicke, K.A., Bodey, G.P., Smith, T., Freireich, E.J.: Treat
ment of adult acute myeloblastic leukemia. In. Modern trends in
human leukemia III Neth, R., Hofschneider, P-H, Manweiler, K. (eds.),
pp 89 Berlin, Heidelberg, New York. Springer 1979 II. Jacquillat,
C., Weil. M., Gamon, M. F., Izrael, V., Schaison, G., Boiron, M.,
Bernard, J.. Treatment of acute myeloblastic leukaemia with RP22050
Brit. Med.J2, 468-469 (1972) 12. Bodey, G.P, Freireich, E.J., Gehan,
E.A., Gutterman, J., Burgess, A. Late intensification therapy for
acute leukemia in remission.J Am. Med. Assn. 235,1021-1025 (1976)
13. Viola, M V, Frazier, M., Wiernik, P, McCredie, K. B., Spiegelman,
S.. Reverse transcriptase in leukocytes of leukemic patients in
remission. N. Engl.J. Med. 294,75-80 (1976) 14. Freeman, A I, Brecher,
M L., Wang, J.J., Sinks, L. F. Intermediate dose methotrexate (IDM)
in childhood acute lymphocytic leukemia. In: Modern trends in human
leukemia III. Neth, R, Hofschneider, P-H., Mannweiler, K. (eds.),
pp. 115. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York. Springer 1979 15. Flament-Durand.
J., Ketelbant-Balasse, P., Maurus, R., Regnier, R., Spehl, M.. Intra
cerebral calcifications appearing during the course of acute lymphocytic
leukemia treated with methotrexate and x-rays. Cancer 35, 319-325
(1975) 16. Margileth, D. A., Poplack, D. G, Pizzo, P. A., Leventhal,
B. G .Blindness during remission in two patients with acute lymphoblastic
leukemia. Cancer 39,58-6 I ( 1977) 17 Capizzi, R. Biochemical interaction
between asparaginase (A'ase) and methotrexate (MTX) in leukemia.
Proc Am. Assn. Cancer Res. 15,77 ( 1974) 18. Haghbin, M, Tan, C.,
Clarkson, B, Mike, V., Burchenal, J., Murphy, M L.. Treatment of
acute lymphoblastic leukemia in children with prophylactic intrathecal
methotrexate and intensive systemic chemotherapy. Cancer Res. 35,807-811
(1975) 19 Lister, TA, Roberts, M.M, Brearley, R.L., Cullen, M.H.,
Greaves, MF. Prognostic f'actors in adult acute lymphoblastic leukaemia
In. Modern trends in human leukemia III. Neth, R., Hofschneider,
P.-H., Mannweiler, K. (eds.), pp 99. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York.
Springer 1979 20. Henderson, E.S., Glidewell, 0. Combination therapy
ofadult patients with acute lympho cytic leukemia (AII) Proc. Am.
Assn Cancer Res. 15,102 (1974) 21. Capizzi, R., Castro, 0, Aspnes,
G., Bobrow, S., Bertino, J., Finch, S., Pearson, H.: Treatment of
acute lymphocytic leukemia (ALL) with intermittent high dose methotrexate
(MTX) and asparaginase (A'ase). Proc Am Soc. Clin. Oncol.15, 182
(1974) 22. Bleyer, W.A., Drake, J C., Chabner, B.A.: Neurotoxicity
and elevated cerebrospinal fluid methotrexate concentration in meningeal
leukemia. N. EnglJ. Med. 289, 770-773 (1973) 23. Simone, J V, Aur,
R.J. A., Hustu, H.O., Verzosa, M.. Trends in the treatment of childhood
leukemia. In. Modern trends in human leukemia II. Neth, R., Gallo,
R.C., Mannweiler, K., Moloney, W. C. (eds), pp. 263-269. Munich:
J. F. Lehmanns Verlag 1976 24. Catovsky. In this monograph. Neth,
R., Hofschneider, P-H, Mannweiler, K. (eds.), pp. 107. Berlin, Heidelberg,
New York. Springer 1979 25. McPhedran, P., Heath, C. W., Jr.. Acute
leukemia occuring during chronic lymphocytic leu kemia. Blood 35,
7-11 (1970) 26. Mertelsmann, R, Koziner, B., Filippa, D. A., Grossbard,
E., Incefy, G., Moore, M. AS., Clarkson, B. D. Clinical significance
ofTdT, cell surface markers and CFU-C in 297 patients with hematopoietic
neoplasias. In Modern trends in human leukemia III. Neth, R., Hof
schneider, P-H, Mannweiler, K. (eds.), pp. 131. Berlin, Heidelberg,
New York: Springer 1979 27. Marks, S.M, Baltimore, D., McCaffrey,
R.P.. Terminal transferase as a predictor of initial responsiveness
to vincristine and prednisone in blastic chronic myelogenous leukemia.
N. Engl.J. Med 298,812-814 (1978) 28. Barr, R. D, Watt, J.. Preliminary
evidence for the common origin of a lymphomyeloid complex in man.
Acta Haematol. 60,29-35 ( 1978)
|